Every Trader Joe’s is stocked with multiple products that fans obsess over, track online, and sometimes even fight over in stores. But what ignites such a frenzy about a simple snack or pantry staple like these?
We’ll, let’s find out by taking a look at the top 14 Trader Joe’s Cult Classics that sell out every time. But be warned: you might want to make a list for your next trip to this awesome store.
1. Everything But the Bagel Seasoning
This seasoning is not just for bagels. The tiny jar filled with sesame, garlic, and onion has become a major must-have for eggs, popcorn, and even vegetables and salads.
Copycats have tried to match the flavor of this delicious seasoning, but nothing compares to Trader Joe’s version. The next time you see it in store, you might have to grab two. You will quickly see why it flies off the shelves.
2. Mandarin Orange Chicken
When this amazing chicken dish is in stock, carts are typically piled high with this dinner shortcut. It is crunchy, tangy, and so much better than any takeout.
This frozen dish has inspired late-night runs and near cult-like devotion. But what is its secret? Of course, it’s the zesty sauce and easy prep. Few things compare to the sheer relief one feels spotting this classic after a two-week drought.
3. Unexpected Cheddar
Unexpected Cheddar is smooth, crumbly, and way sharper than most grocery cheeses, which is why it has become a legend among cheese aficionados.
This product has hundreds of five-star reviews, and people still keep coming back for it. Many shoppers even buy extra for fear of running out. If you spot it, grab at least two. You won’t regret it.
4. Cauliflower Gnocchi
Who would’ve thought that cauliflower could ever taste like pasta? This low-cal, gluten-free item is convincing enough to win over regular gnocchi lovers.
Cauliflower Gnocchi made such waves that cauliflower growers struggled to meet demand after the product was launched. Want pasta comfort without the carbs? Then you should try it out.
5. Speculoos Cookie Butter
What began as an imported treat has become a full-blown American craze. This cinnamon-ginger cookie spread quickly gained a devoted following, so much so that stores imposed purchase limits to keep hoarders at bay.
Fans slather it on toast, drizzle it over waffles, and swirl it into ice cream. This is one you have to try for yourself.
6. Dark Chocolate Peanut Butter Cups
Peanut butter cup lovers can all agree that Trade Joe’s version is richer, darker, and all grown up.
Some fans have claimed that these cups are just too addictive to keep at home. Grab a handful, and suddenly, half the box is gone! If you see these near the checkout counter, treat yourself before someone else does.
7. Joe-Joe’s Cookies
Oreo devotees are divided every time Trader Joe’s restocks its Joe-Joe’s. Some swear the creamier filling and crispier cookie leave other brands in the dust, while skeptics remain loyal to the classic.
Still, each restock sparks heated cookie debates online and in-store. Is it the richer cocoa? A dose of nostalgia? Whatever the reason, fans don’t hesitate to clear shelves—often buying them by the case.
8. Chili Onion Crunch
At first glance, you might think Chili Onion Crunch is just another condiment, but if you try just one spoonful, you will get the hype.
This condiment is spicy, savory, and packed with texture. It is a cult favorite you never knew you needed. Fans like to toss it on pizza, eggs, noodles, and sometimes even ice cream.
9. Hold the Cone! Mini Ice Cream Cones
These tiny, crunchy, and perfectly portioned mini cones are pure joy. Kids love them because of their small size, while adults love their guilt-free treat factor.
But what is their secret? Real chocolate coating and classic flavors. Grab a few of these the next time you see them.
10. Triple Ginger Snaps
Ginger, crystallized ginger, and ground ginger come together to create a cookie that is so spicy-sweet that shoppers are often seen racing down the snack aisle for them.
They’re crunchy, punchy, and are perfect for afternoon tea and midnight cravings. Addicted regulars claim they know the restock schedule by heart.
11. Butternut Squash Mac & Cheese
Butternut squash mac and cheese is usually available in the fall, and loyalists are known to buy boxes by the dozen.
This creamy, cheesy, subtly sweet product is perfectly seasonal. It’s so good that some fans freeze extras for off-season cravings. Prices even spike in online auctions.
12. Organic Coconut Aminos
Coconut aminos, the go-to soy sauce substitute for the allergy crowd, fly off shelves thanks to trendy home cooks and special diets.
With lower sodium, a subtly sweet-savory taste, and endless uses, it’s a must-have for Whole30, Paleo, and gluten-free fans.
13. Broccoli & Kale Slaw
Would you believe it if someone told you that a bagged salad could trigger a shopping frenzy? The broccoli and kale slaw is a favorite thanks to the tangy dressing, the crunchy seeds, and just-picked freshness.
Instagram foodies swear by it, and regulars plan their dinners around its limited availability.
14. Teeny Tiny Avocados
Why do some shoppers set their alarms for fruit? Trader Joe’s Teeny Tiny Avocados are the perfect ripeness, size, and portion, no waste, no waiting.
Each shipment is known to sell out within hours, leading to whispered tips and excited texts among savvy shoppers.